Accueil / Résidents / Do we need a radical redefinition of secularism? A critique of Charles Taylor

Do we need a radical redefinition of secularism? A critique of Charles Taylor

FacebookTwitter

Murat Akan, "Do we need a radical redefinition of secularism? A critique of Charles Taylor", Politics and Religion, 2023:1-21.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S1755048323000287

Extrait

Charles Taylor's “radical redefinition of secularism” has a significant place in the post-9/11 research on secularism. He replaces secularism's “old” paradigm, separation between state and religious institutions, with a “new” one, responding to diversity. Taylor appeals to French laïcité in-itself as the old paradigm. With an analysis of the parliamentary debates at the institutional origins of the old paradigm in the Third French Republic, this article questions whether Taylor's redefinition of secularism is truly radical. This historical intervention in Taylor's “radical redefinition” reformulates his novelty as the reconfiguration of the relation between generality of laws and meaning worlds in the institutional response to diversity. The Third Republic pushed generality in laws against diverse meaning worlds. Taylor (with Jocelyn Maclure) demands that general laws reasonably accommodate “meaning-giving convictions.” I explore this reversal and argue that it's questionable Taylor offers a radical redefinition of secularism—or even that we need one.

En savoir + : voir site de l'éditeur

La politique de la dé-démocratisation : Une analyse comparative de l'Inde, de la Turquie et de la deuxième République française
01 septembre 2020 - 30 juin 2021
24787
Murat Akan
30970
2023
Murat Akan